Carbon print

A carbon print is a photographic print with an image consisting of pigmented gelatin, rather than of silver or other metallic particles suspended in a uniform layer of gelatin, as in typical black-and-white prints, or of chromogenic dyes, as in typical photographic color prints.

In the original version of the printing process, carbon tissue (a temporary support sheet coated with a layer of gelatin mixed with a pigment—originally carbon black, from which the name derives) is bathed in a potassium dichromate sensitizing solution, dried, then exposed to strong ultraviolet light through a photographic negative, hardening the gelatin in proportion to the amount of light reaching it. The tissue is then developed by treatment with warm water, which dissolves the unhardened gelatin. The resulting pigment image is physically transferred to a final support surface, either directly or indirectly. In an important early 20th century variation of the process, contact with a conventional silver bromide paper print, rather than exposure to light, was used to selectively harden the gelatin. A wide variety of colored pigments can be used instead of carbon black.

The process can produce images of very high quality which are exceptionally resistant to fading and other deterioration. It was developed in the mid-19th century in response to concerns about the fading of early types of silver-based black-and-white prints, which was already becoming apparent within a relatively few years of their introduction.

An Overview and History of Carbon (Pigment) Printing

The carbon process, initially a black-and-white process using lampblack (carbon black), was invented by Alphonse Poitevin in 1855. The process was later adapted to color, through the use of pigments, by Louis Arthur Ducos du Hauron in 1868. Carbon printing remained commercially popular through the first half of the 20th century. It was replaced over time by the dye-transfer process, chromogenic, dye-bleach (or dye destruction, i.e., Cibachrome) and, now, digital printing processes. The efficiencies gained through these more modern automated processes relegated carbon printing to the commercial backwaters in the latter half of the 20th century. It is now only found in the darkrooms of the rare enthusiast and a few exotic labs.

Carbon printing is based on the fact that gelatin, when sensitized to light by a dichromate, is hardened and made insoluble in water when exposed to ultraviolet light. Because of the comparative insensitivity of the material, sunlight or another strong source of UV light is normally used in order to minimize the required exposure time. To make a full-color print, three negatives photographed through red, green and blue filters are printed on dichromate-sensitized sheets of pigmented gelatin (traditionally called "carbon tissue" regardless of the pigment incorporated) containing, respectively, cyan, magenta and yellow pigments. They are developed in warm water, which dissolves the unhardened gelatin, leaving a colored relief image that is thickest where it received the strongest exposure. The three images are then transferred, one at a time, onto a final support such as a heavy sheet of smooth gelatin-sized paper. Usually, the yellow image is transferred first, then the magenta image is applied on top of it, great care being taken to superimpose it in exact register, and then the cyan image is similarly applied. A fourth black pigment "key" layer is sometimes added, as in mechanical printing processes, to improve edge definition and mask any spurious color cast in the dark areas of the image, but it is not a traditional component.

The resulting finished print, whether composed of several layers and in full color or having only a single monochrome layer, exhibits a very slight bas-relief effect and a variation of texture on its surface, both distinctive characteristics of a carbon print. The process is time-consuming and labor-intensive. Each color carbon print requires three, or four, round trips in the darkroom to create the finished print. An individual, using existing pigmented sheets and separations, can prepare, print and process enough material, 60 sheets including the support, to produce about twelve 20" x 24" four-color prints in a 40 hour work week. However, this investment of time and effort can create prints of outstanding visual quality and proven archival permanence.

Because the carbon printing process uses pigments instead of dyes, it is capable of producing a far more archivally stable (permanent) print than any of the other color processes. Good examples of the color stability of pigments can be found in the paintings of the great masters, the true colors of which, in many cases, have survived all these centuries. A more contemporary example of the color stability of pigments is found in the paints used on automobiles today, which must survive intense daily exposure to very harsh lighting, under extreme conditions. The useful life of many (but not all) pigment formulations has been projected out to be several centuries and beyond (perhaps millennia, if cave paintings of Lascaux, the wall paintings in the tombs of the Valley of the Kings and the frescoes of Pompeii are relevant examples), often being limited only to the useful life of the particular support used. Additionally, the use of pigment also produces a wider color gamut than any of the other color processes, allowing for a greater range and subtlety of color reproduction.

Though carbon printing always has been, and remains, a labor intensive, time consuming and technologically demanding process, there are still those that prefer the high aesthetic of its remarkable beauty and longevity over all other processes.

Chronological History of Carbon (Pigment) Printing

Date Name Nationality Remarks
1798 Louis Nicolas Vauquelin French Influence of light on silver chromate
1826 Joseph Nicéphore Niépce French First permanent photograph of the image formed by a camera lens
1832 Gustav Suckow French Chromic acid salts are light sensitive, even without silver
1839 Sir John Herschel English Introduction of the word "photography", early experiments with creating prints in various colors
1839 Mungo Ponton English Action of light on paper coated with potassium dichromate + washing = fixed image
1840 Henri Becquerel French Action of light on paper coated with potassium dichromate + iodine fumes = fixed image
1852 William Henry Fox Talbot English Dichromated gelatin rendered insoluble by exposure to light
1855 Alphonse Poitevin French Invents photographic printing by dichromated pigment process
1855 James Clerk Maxwell English Color photography by three-color analysis and synthesis, proposed in passing in a paper on color vision
1858 L'abbé Laborde French Principle of exposure through the base then transfer from one base to another (see Fargier)
1860 Fargier French Principle of exposure through the base then transfer from one base to another (see Laborde) but the image is reversed
1860 Blaise French Double transfer to get a non-reversed image
1861 James Clerk Maxwell English Demonstration of photographic color reproduction by synthesis (additive method, three images superimposed by projection through filters)
1862 Louis Ducos du Hauron French Photographic color printing by the three-color subtractive method proposed in an unpublished paper
1863 Pouncy English Uses sensitized inks
1863 Poitevin French Modification of his process: insolubility of the pigmented gelatin then solubility by exposure through a positive film
1864 Joseph Wilson Swan English Swan process: uses rubber for the transfer
1867 Charles Cros French Unaware of work being done by Louis Ducos du Hauron (see 1862) invents similar methods for photographic color reproduction
1868 Marion French Procédé Marion: Uses an albuminated paper for the transfer
1868 Louis Ducos du Hauron French Patents the basic principles of most of the practical color photography processes subsequently developed
1869 Charles Cros French Publishes Solution générale du problème de la photographie des couleurs
1869 Louis Ducos du Hauron French Publishes Les couleurs en photographie, solution du problème
1869 Jeanrenaud French Procédé Jeanrenaud: Improvement of the transfer
1869 Jeanrenaud French Double transfer with an opal glass
1870 Gobert French 1870-1873 printing on metal plates
1873 Marion French Mariotype
1873 Hermann Vogel German Discovers dye sensitization of silver halides, making creation of three-color separation negatives practical
1878 Louis Ducos du Hauron French Publishes improved methods of color photography and printing by the carbon process
1878 Fredéric Artigues French Charbon velours
1881 Charles Cros French Tricolor process prints presented to the Academie des Sciences (French Academy of Sciences)
1889 Artigues French Papiers charbon velours
1893 Victor Artigues French Carbon velours à tons continus de 1893 à 1910
1894 Ladeveze Rouille French Papier gomme-chrome
1899 Thomas Manly English Ozotype derived from mariotype
1899 Henri Theodore Fresson French Procédé Fresson: sold in USA between 1927 and 1939 by Edward Alenias. Bought by Luis Nadeau, Canada, 1979
1900 Fresson French Papier charbon Satin then papier Arvel to be processed with chlorine
1902 Robert Krayn American N.P.G. Process: tricolor carbon process distributed in France by La Société Industrielle de Photographie
1905 Thomas Manly English Ozobrome process: instead of exposure to light, contact with a silver bromide print selectively hardens the dichromated gelatin
1910 Arbuthnot English Dichromated watercolor or dichromated lavish
1911 Dovertype English Sold in England by the Dover Street Studio, London, 1911-1914
1913 S. Manners American Early form of three color carbro 1913-1922
1919 H.F. Farmer English Carbro process based on Manly's ozobromie, Sold by Autotype in London
1920 H.F. Farmer English Trichrome Carbro process marketed from 1920 to 1960 by Autotype
1923 H.J.C. Deeks American Raylo: three color carbon
1950 KoloroÏd American Dichromated colloid: carbon transfer process
1951 Pierre Fresson French Quadrichromie Fresson
1965 3M American 3M Electrocolor Print 1965 to 1978
1977 Kwik-Print American Light Impressions Corp, Rochester
1982 Archival Color Co. American San Francisco: quad-color carbon process
1983 George Griffin Canadian Quad halftone, duotone and mono contone carbon until from 1983 to 2006 Private collection of photographers work only.
1985 Polaroid American Laser separation + transfer of pigment on a base. Stopped in 1986: Polaroid Permanent Pigment Print
1986 Jerry Kuska & Douglas Madeley American & Canadian Four color carbon prints, Limited Edition Photo/Graphics, Santa Cruz, California, until 1991
1993 Charles Berger American Ultrastable Color System. Pigmented quadrichromy
1998 Racey Gilbert American Ataraxia Pigment Prints, until 2004
2006 - now Tod Gangler American Art & Soul Photo, Seattle, Washington, Four color carbon prints and metallic quadtone black & white carbons
2006 - now John Bladen Bentley Canadian Verve Gallery of Photography, living in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, Four colour carbon transfer prints

See also

External links